Tuesday, August 10, 2010

The real illegal immigration problem: Lazy Elitest Americans

The real problem with illegal immigration isn't illegal immigrants- it is lazy American Citizens who don't think others deserve the same standard of living they have, combined with ridiculously low fines for their arrogance and criminal behavior.

Case in point from the article:

Annette — who agreed to give only her middle name — owns a two-bedroom condo in Phoenix, which she rents out. Her last tenant, a smoker, just moved away, and in order to fix the lingering cigarette smell, she needs a paint job.

Annette's painter is not authorized to work in the U.S. In fact, he's not authorized to live here, either. His name is Raphael, and he's cheap. Annette says an American painter quoted her $1,200 for the job. Raphael charges $500.

Annette believes American prices are inflated, so paying Raphael the lower wage is justified
.

So Annette doesn't believe Americans deserve their standard of living- does she include her own family in that? Is she willing to lower her rent so that the poor illegal immigrants like Raphael can rent from her?

"If Raphael didn't come, he would work in a maquiladora in Juarez, and he would make $1 an hour or $2 an hour, whereas here he can make $500 in a matter of five hours," Annette says. "So I have no problem giving him the keys to this condo, because I know he'll do a good job."

Annette is breaking federal law. If caught, she could face a $375 fine. She's small potatoes to federal agents. But things are getting more hostile for people like Annette in Arizona. One provision of the state's controversial immigration law that went into effect last month makes it a crime to slow traffic while picking up day laborers. That's a common practice on some Phoenix street corners.

So let's do the math. Original American job cost, $1200. Annette's worst case scenario: $500 to Raphael, $375 fine. $875 is a lot less than $1200- so of course she's well ahead to hire the illegal immigrant.

I wonder if she'd care if the fine was $50,000?

But better yet- if she really wants to save money, why not learn to paint? I recently had to repair and paint my bathroom- so I asked my dad, a handyman, to help. Total repair bill $210, including a new fan/light/heat unit to prevent damage in the future. Doing the labor ourselves was the difference.

2 comments:

Whitey Lawful's Blogspot: The spirit of the law is greater then the letter. said...

The rationale that immigrants are not coming here legally is a front for an actual concern regarding the encrouching Mexican culture. The bulk of Americans take an elitist stance where they are not going to work for less the ten dollars an hour, not even concidering less.

Ted Seeber said...

Given the cost of raising a family these days- I don't think ANY job is worth less than $20/hr. Artificially lowering the going wage is an attempt to cheat the law of supply and demand- which if it was allowed to affect minimum wage the same way it affects CEO pay, would easily be $20/hr by now.

As for legal vs illegal- a country has a right to control it's borders for national security, and back in 1986, we gave an amnesty in return for tougher immigration laws. Except, nobody's enforcing those laws, even minimally. And the legal path to citizenship has been clogged with inefficiency.

Creative Commons License
Oustside The Asylum by Ted Seeber is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.
Based on a work at http://outsidetheaustisticasylum.blogspot.com.